Skip to main content

Parallels between Jerry Seinfeld and Jack Benny

By Jon

But it is something has always struck me about the similarities between Jack Benny and Jerry Seinfeld.

For instance:
  • BOTH were comedians
  • BOTH had historically successful (legendary?) comedy programs
  • BOTH surrounded themselves with a tight 'gang'
  • BOTH deferred the best jokes (or lines) to their fellow cast members.
  • BOTH were content to be the butt of the joke (when appropriate)
  • BOTH broke down the 4th wall (Benny talked to audience, Jerry did it via
  • Stand Up Somedy)
  • BOTH were usually the conduit for story lines (very involving only Mary/Phil or Kramer/Elaine for example)
  • BOTH involved preparing for and sometimes performing there show as part of
  • their situational comedy.
Even the cast member pairings
Each show had a wonderfully talented second tier of actors/actresses as well. From Jerry's parents to Professor LeBlanc, from From the 'Soup Nazi' to Jack's store clerk when Christmas shopping.

 Both of them had shows which, to some degree, had something to do with life in their homes. Jack in his home and Jerry in his New York apartment.

Dennis Day and Rochester did a job similar to what George Costanza did on Jerry's show.

Both had humorous storylines which people remember today regarding money. There was Jack's miserliness and when Jerry tried to save money by allowing Elaine to design and sew him "The Frilly Pirate Shirt".

Talented writers like Jack Benny and Milt Josefsberg to Jerry Seinfeld and Larry David.

Jack started doing live performances and then used the medium of the day (Radio) and transitioned to the new medium (TV).

 Jerry started with Live stand up and then used the popular medium (TV) and eventually transitioned to the new medium (Streaming content)

Jack Benny and the TV show "Frasier" are also similar -- especially the comedic timing, fast when it had to be,
medium as needed, slow to let some things soak in. I don't know if it was all led by Kelsey Grammer, avowed admirer of Benny, or if the writers and the rest of the cast all caught the "Benny bug," but they did a fine job.



Labels:

Comments

  1. IIzThatIIzFebruary 9, 2021 at 10:55 PM

    The most obvious "parallel" between 'The Jack Benny Radio Program' and 'Seinfeld', is that both were shows about "nothing".

    The 'situations' created by Jack Benny and his writers revolved about the ordinary and mundane. Just common everyday occurrences. Jack shopping for Christmas gifts, or the Seinfeld cast shopping for a TV. Jack and the World Series, or Jerry at a Met's game. Dennis Days' and Mary's relatives .. Jerry and Georges relatives. Parallels abound.

    What Seinfeld was able to copy was the comedy of dull, ordinary situations experienced by 'everyman'. Neither show delved into manufactured comedy hi-jinks. Just the ordinary experiences of a well-defined small group of friends.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Was Jack Benny Gay?": The Amount of Weight In Jack Benny's Loafers

By Jon
While doing research for an article I came across an unexpected search result: "Was Jack Benny Gay?" There was no more than the question as previously stated from the original poster, but the replies made for interesting reading, ranging from: Jack Benny Celebrating his 39th Birthday "Of course not, he was a well known skirt-chaser in his youth, and he was married to Mary Livingston for many years" "Sure he was, everyone in Hollywood with the possible exception of John Wayne was and is homosexual!" "Part of Benny's "schtick" was his limp-wristed hand-to-face gestures. He was not gay, but emphasized what his fans observed as "acting like a girl" for humor. While heterosexual Benny tried to gay it up, many really gay actors or comedians in those days tried to act as "straight" as they could muster." "... the idea behind his character was to have him a little on the ambiguous side. His charact...
48 comments
Read more

OLD TIME RADIO ACTORS AND THEIR ROLES, AND OLD TIME RADIO PROGRAM

By Jon
Old Time Radio Actor's Name, Character Played, Program Aaker, Lee Rusty Rin-Tin-Tin Aames, Marlene McWilliams, Lauralee Story of Holly Sloan, The Abbott, Judith Lawson, Agnes Aldrich Family, The Abbott, Minabelle Sothern, Mary Life of Mary Sothern, The Ace, Goodman Ace, Goodman Easy Aces Ace, Goodman Ace, Goodman Mister Ace and Jane Ace, Jane Ace, Jane Easy Aces Ace, Jane Ace, Jane Mister Ace and Jane Adams, Bill Cotter, Jim Rosemary Adams, Bill Hagen, Mike Valiant Lady Adams, Bill Roosevelt, Franklin Delano March of Time, The Adams, Bill Salesman Travelin' Man Adams, Bill Stark, Daniel Roses and Drums Adams, Bill Whelan, Father Abie's Irish Rose Adams, Bill Wilbur, Matthew Your Family and Mine Adams, Bill Young, Sam Pepper Young's Family Adams, Edith Gilman, Ethel Those Happy Gilmans Adams, Franklin Mayor of a model city Secret City Adams, Franklin Jr. Skinner, Skippy Skippy Adams, Franklin Pierce Emcee Word Game, The Adams, Guila Mattie Step M...
Post a Comment
Read more

Old Time Radio Shows "Transcribed" Explained

By Jon
What does it mean on old time radio shows when you hear the show is "Transcribed"? During the Golden Age of Radio , "transcribed" programs were recorded and sent to stations or networks on a disc running at 16 rps. The discs are larger than 33 1/3s. "Transcribed" means it was recorded on a disc. "Recorded" was a term that was known, of course, but not used very much in Radio's Golden Age. During the era, it was also considered very important to distinguish which shows went out live and which were recorded (transcribed), so if a show was transcribed it was announced as such.  "Transcribed" was a colloquialism of the era. One reason they came up with it was because there was still enough skittishness about recording that "pre-recorded" sounded a little obscene inside the industry. CBS and NBC were live through the '30s and '40s. Yet line transcriptions were made for either the sponsor or its ad agency. ...
8 comments
Read more